EN
No booking fees. Free cancellation on most cars
Save by finding great deals and securing low price rentals
Compare rental car prices from leading companies in Deer Park, NY with Road Genius. From small economy cars to large SUVs and minivans, you'll find vehicles at low prices in convenient locations. Booking in town helps you dodge airport surcharges at JFK, LaGuardia or Islip and puts you straight on the Long Island Expressway for quick drives to Manhattan, the Hamptons or North Fork wine country.
| Location | Advantages | Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Deer Park Local Offices | Lower rates than airports, Calmer pickup experience, No airport surcharges | Limited hours (often closed Sundays), Need to arrange transport from airports/train stations |
| JFK/LaGuardia Airports | Immediate pickup upon arrival, All major brands available, Extended hours | Higher rates due to airport fees, Longer wait times during peak periods |
| Islip MacArthur Airport (ISP) | Closer to Deer Park (around 15 miles/24 km), Generally shorter wait times | Fewer rental companies, May have limited vehicle selection |
On average, car rentals in Deer Park (NY) cost around $104 per day, with the lowest-priced rentals starting at $28 per day.
Skip the airports: Collect in a Deer Park neighborhood office to dodge airport facility fees and save roughly $10–25 per day. Just double-check the shorter opening hours.
Peak season? Book 2-4 weeks out: Summer and holiday weekends on Long Island sell out fast; comparing early keeps prices sane. Off-peak months often stay cheap until the last minute.
Search nearby ZIP codes: Quotes from Huntington, Bay Shore, or even Islip MacArthur Airport can undercut Deer Park on certain dates. Our tool lets you flip between locations in seconds.
Shift your pickup to mid-week: Starting on a Tuesday or Wednesday usually costs less than a Friday or Saturday grab. Adjust dates and rerun the search to see the drop.
Bring your own extras: Pack a phone mount, GPS, or booster seat and refuel yourself to avoid $5-15 daily accessory fees plus inflated fuel charges.
Beat the toll program fee: Register the rental's plate at tollsbymailny.com within 48 hours so you only pay the actual NY tolls, not the $3.95+ daily "convenience" charge.
Finding a Spot:
Local Driving Rules:
Book a rental to get to:
Manhattan – museums, theaters
Montauk Point – lighthouse, Atlantic beaches
North Fork via Riverhead – wineries, farm stands
Jones Beach State Park – boardwalk, concerts
What documents do I need to rent a car in Deer Park?
You need a valid driver's license, a credit card and proof of insurance. If you are visiting from another country, you can use your valid foreign license. We recommend you get an International Driving Permit (IDP) if your license isn't in English. Always carry your passport, license and rental agreement in the car.
Are there age restrictions for renting in New York?
In New York, you can rent a car at 18, but companies will charge a young-driver fee if you are under 25. By law, the most they can charge is $35 per day for drivers 21-24 and $84 per day for drivers 18-20, though some companies may charge less. A membership like USAA can sometimes get the fee waived for drivers 21-24 at certain companies, but it is rare for drivers 18-20 to get a waiver.
How does the security deposit work?
When you rent a car, the company places a security hold on your credit card. The hold is usually for about $200 more than the rental cost. This isn't a real charge, and the company will release it after you return the car in good condition. Off-airport locations often accept debit cards, but they may ask you for extra paperwork and place a larger security hold.
What should I do if I encounter mechanical issues with my rental?
You should keep the rental company's roadside assistance number handy. You can usually find it on the key fob or contract. Most companies provide 24/7 help or will get you a replacement car. In an emergency, call 911. In New York, you should get a police report if there is any noticeable damage.
Can I take a one-way rental from Deer Park to another location?
Yes, but the company might charge you extra fees for a one-way rental. Some companies waive drop-off fees inside the NY metro area, but you will usually have to pay a fee if you drop the car in another state. You should always check the contract before you confirm a one-way rental.
Popular Countries
24/7 Support