EN
No booking fees. Free cancellation on most cars
Save by finding great deals and securing low price rentals
Road Genius makes it easy to find great car rental deals in Riverhead, New York. Compare rates and make reservations in one place. Pick up your vehicle in downtown Riverhead or at nearby Islip MacArthur Airport and be on your way to Long Island wineries, beaches and the Hamptons in under an hour.
| Location | Advantages | Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Riverhead Local Offices | Lower rates than airports, No airport surcharges, Convenient for eastern Long Island exploration | Limited hours (often business hours only), May have smaller vehicle selection |
| Islip MacArthur Airport (ISP) | Closest airport (around 25 miles/40 km), Some major rental companies | More limited selection than larger airports, Still requires drive to reach Riverhead |
| JFK/LaGuardia Airports | Largest selection of vehicles and companies, Extended hours | 70+ miles (113 km) from Riverhead, Heavy traffic when traveling east (especially weekends), Higher rates along airport fees |
On average, car rentals in Riverhead cost around $103 per day, with the lowest-priced rentals starting at $22 per day.
Compare pickup spots: price-check Riverhead town offices against Islip (ISP) and JFK/LGA. Local desks skip airport fees and can be cheaper even after the train or rideshare from the terminal.
Shift your calendar: mid-week or shoulder season (early May, mid-Sept) sees lower demand on the forks — rates often drop versus Friday-Sunday in July/August.
Lock in early for peak weekends: Memorial Day, July 4th, Labor Day and harvest season sell out. Booking 3-4 weeks ahead keeps options open and avoids last-minute surcharges.
Play with rental length: a 5-7 day "weekly" rate often beats four separate daily rates. Even if you return the car a bit early you can still come out ahead.
Where to Park:
Local Driving Rules:
Rent a car so you can get to:
The Hamptons – beaches, dining, shopping
Montauk Point – lighthouse, surf beaches
North Fork wine country – wineries, farm stands
Greenport village – waterfront, maritime museum
What documents do I need to rent a car in Riverhead?
You will need a valid driver's license and a major credit card. Some companies also accept debit cards, but they might have extra rules. You usually don't need to show proof of your own car insurance. New York law makes sure all rentals have basic liability coverage. The rental company might ask about your coverage or offer you extra insurance. If you're visiting from another country, you should bring a valid foreign license, your passport and an International Driving Permit if your license isn't in English.
How far in advance should I book a rental car for summer travel to Riverhead?
For summer weekends, especially holiday weekends, you should book at least 3–4 weeks in advance. For busy times like July 4th, Memorial Day and Labor Day, you should reserve a car as soon as you know your travel dates. Rentals can sell out completely during these times.
Can I rent a car in Riverhead and return it in Manhattan or at an airport?
Yes, you can rent a car one-way, but the company might charge you extra fees. Some rental agencies in the NY metro area have better deals for one-way trips. Always check your contract and ask about drop-off fees before you book a one-way rental.
What's the best strategy for visiting wineries with a rental car?
The North Fork has over 40 wineries. If everyone in your group plans to taste wine, you could rent a driver for your rental car or join a tour. Another option is to pick someone to be the designated driver and visit fewer wineries in one day. Many wineries also serve food, which can help you slow down your wine tasting.
Are there age restrictions for renting in Riverhead?
Most companies require you to be at least 21 years old. They will add extra charges for drivers under 25, usually about $25–$30 per day. In New York, you can rent a car starting at age 18, but companies charge much higher fees for drivers under 21, around $70 per day. If you have a membership like USAA or AAA, you might be able to lower these fees.
Popular Countries
24/7 Support