EN
No booking fees. Free cancellation on most cars
Save by finding great deals and securing low price rentals
Finding a car rental in Utica, NY is simple with Road Genius. Compare prices from dozens of brands across New York with no booking fees. Pick up a low priced rental downtown or at nearby Syracuse Hancock or Albany International airports, then cruise I-90 to the Adirondacks, Cooperstown or Turning Stone with unlimited miles. Filter deals by vehicle size, AWD and free cancellation to lock in the ride that matches your plans in minutes.
| Location | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Utica City Rentals | • Lower base rates (no airport fees) • Convenient for visitors already in Utica • Locations near downtown and train station |
• Limited hours (business hours only) • Smaller vehicle selection • Few allow after-hours pickup |
| Syracuse Hancock Int'l (SYR) | • Largest selection of vehicles • Major rental companies on-site • Extended hours aligned with flight schedules |
• 55 miles (89 km) from Utica (around 1-hour drive) • Airport concession fees (around 10-11%) • Transportation needed to/from Utica |
| Albany International (ALB) | • Good selection of vehicles • Major rental companies on-site • Extended hours |
• 95 miles (153 km) from Utica (around 1.5-hour drive) • Airport fees • Long distance from Utica |
On average, car rentals in Utica - New Hartford cost around $70 per day, with the lowest-priced rentals starting at $24 per day.
Compare city vs airport pickups: Utica downtown depots skip the 10-11 % airport concession fee and often beat Syracuse/Albany rates if you're already in town (train, bus, or rideshare in).
Time your trip: Late winter weekdays and early spring see the cheapest prices (economy cars ≈ $35-40/day). Summer weekends and fall-foliage dates spike, so lock those in a few weeks ahead or shift your dates if you can.
Skip the AWD upsell April–October: Roads to Cooperstown or the western Adirondacks are paved and plowed; a standard 2WD car will do unless you're here in deep-snow months.
Align pickup/return with business hours: Most city branches close early; showing up late triggers after-hours fees or an unwanted airport detour.
Look at weekly rates: Needing the car 5-7 days? A flat weekly price often equals four daily rates in Utica, so extending by a day or two can drop the total.
Pay tolls smartly: If I-90 is a one-off, decline the $4-7/day transponder and pay online within 48 hours—cheaper than the device fee for light toll use.
| Area | Street Parking | Garages/Lots | Tips |
|---|---|---|---|
| Downtown Utica | • Metered spots • Some free spots with time limits |
• Municipal lots available | • Meters enforced Mon-Fri 9 AM-6 PM • Free evening and weekend parking in most areas |
| Union Station Area | • Limited street parking • Some metered spots |
• Station parking lot • Public lot across from station |
• Train station lot fills during Amtrak arrivals • Long-term parking available for train passengers |
| Varick Street/Brewery District | • Street parking (free) • Limited availability weekends |
• Small public lots • Some business lots |
• Busiest during evenings and weekends • Arrive early for events |
| Utica College/MVCC Areas | • Campus parking restrictions • Visitor designated areas |
• Campus visitor lots • Time-limited parking |
• Check campus websites for visitor parking • Special event procedures may differ |
Watch for pedestrians in downtown areas
New York State Thruway (I-90): Cashless tolling system
Options for handling tolls:
Get a car to easily:
Adirondack Mountains – Old Forge, trailheads, lakes
Cooperstown – National Baseball Hall of Fame, Otsego Lake
Turning Stone Resort – casino, golf, entertainment
Syracuse – Destiny USA mall, museums, airport access
Erie Canal corridor – museums, canal towns
Local ski areas – Woods Valley, McCauley Mountain
Do I need an AWD vehicle when visiting Utica?
From April through October, a standard 2WD vehicle is all most visitors need. However, during the winter from November to March, we highly recommend an AWD/4WD vehicle, especially if you plan to drive to the Adirondacks or in snowy weather.
What is the best way to handle tolls around Utica?
The main toll road is the New York State Thruway (I-90). Most rental companies can give you a toll transponder for a daily fee plus the cost of the tolls. If you don't use a transponder, cameras will record your license plate for billing and your rental company will add an extra fee. You can also pay your tolls online within 48 hours on the Tolls by Mail website.
Are there any local driving challenges I should be aware of?
In downtown Utica, you'll find a mix of one-way streets and construction projects that can be confusing sometimes. Driving in the winter is your biggest challenge, since lake-effect snow can make road conditions change quickly. In the summer, watch out for more cyclists on the road, especially during the Boilermaker Road Race weekend when many people are training.
Where can I find the best rental rates in Utica?
Rental places in the city often have better rates than the ones at the airport. You can find Enterprise, Hertz and Budget/Avis in Utica. When you compare prices, also think about their business hours and how close they are to where you're staying. If you book 2–3 weeks early, you'll usually get better prices and have more cars to choose from.
Can I take my rental car into the Adirondack Park?
Yes, you can drive your rental car anywhere in the Adirondack Park. Just know that some remote areas have unpaved roads, and your rental agreement might not let you drive on them. Cell service can be spotty in parts of the park, so you should download offline maps and plan your route ahead of time.
Popular Countries
24/7 Support